The Real Presence (after Thomas McGovern)

16 min read Eucharist & the Mass

By Fr. Conor Donnelly

(Proofread)

In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. My Lord and my God, I firmly believe that You are here, that You see me, that You hear me. I adore You with profound reverence. I ask Your pardon for my sins and grace to make this time of prayer fruitful. My Immaculate Mother, Saint Joseph, my father and lord, my guardian angel, intercede for me.

The great nineteenth-century German theologian Matthias Scheeben points out that the mystery of the Eucharist is ontologically joined to the mystery of the Incarnation, just as the mystery of the Incarnation is joined to the Trinity. The Incarnation is the presupposition and the explanation of the Eucharist, just as the eternal generation from the bosom of the Father is a presupposition and explanation of the Incarnation, regarded as the stepping forth of God’s Son into the world.

These mysteries disclose a remarkable analogy in their relationships to one another. All three show us the same Son of God: the first in the bosom of his eternal Father, whence he receives his being; the second in the womb of the Virgin, through which he enters the world; the third in the heart of the Church, where he sojourns by an enduring universal presence among men and unites himself to them.

We see in the Eucharist an expression of the ineffable love of God for us, for he desires to unite himself to us in the closest possible manner. It is clear that he wants to treat us not as his servants, but as his dearly loved children. The full significance of the mystery of the Eucharist is the real incorporation of men and women in Christ, so that they may partake of his life.

That Christ unites himself to us in the Eucharist in such a way as to form one body with us is the clear teaching of sacred Scripture and of the Fathers of the Church. The Fathers emphasize, in the strongest terms, that our union with Christ is not simply a moral one, but one that is real and physical. In the Eucharist, our body is joined to the body of the Logos, and so we become flesh of his flesh.

In Communion, Christ takes us to himself and transforms us. He unites us to himself as branches are united to the vine. With him, our head, we grow into one body. He sustains us with his life.

So completely do we become one with Christ, that we can say with all truth that we belong to the person of Christ and, in a sense, are Christ himself. Saint Leo the Great says, “Nothing else is aimed at, in our partaking of the body and blood of Christ, than that we change into what we consume, and even bear in our spirit and flesh him in whom we have died, been buried, and have risen.”

We share in the glory the Son has received from the Father. We are deified. Thus, the Council of Trullo in 691 said, “God who is offered and distributed for our salvation, the salvation of souls and bodies, deifies those who receive him.”

Saint Cyril of Jerusalem is even more explicit. “When you partake,” he says, “of the body and blood of Christ, you are made one body and one blood with him. Receiving his flesh and his blood into our members in this way, we become Christ-bearers.”

According to Blessed Peter, we are made “partakers of the divine nature” (2 Pet. 1:4). In the context of the supernatural grace of divine sonship, the mystery of the Eucharist appears in its full beauty as the seal and crown of our union with God. In the Eucharist, God continues his divine life in us.

Scheeben explains, “On the analogy of natural bread, we tend to regard the Eucharist as a food that is worthy of the children of God and that serves to sustain and strengthen their divine life. But if this food unites us in a special way to Christ, it must do more than sustain the life of the children of God. It must provide a deeper basis for their dignity and life, and bestow on them an essentially higher beauty than they would otherwise have had.”

By means of the Eucharist, then, we become the body of the only begotten Son of God. For he has not only taken his flesh from our flesh, but has returned to us the flesh he assumed. In the Eucharist, we receive the life of God. For eucharistic Communion has the function of nourishing the children of God.

The idea of man’s incorporation in Christ stands out as the distinguishing note in the significance of the Eucharist. In promising the Eucharist, Our Lord said, “He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed” (John 6:54–55).

As the hymn Ave verum reminds us, the flesh offered at the Last Supper and immolated on the cross was the same flesh Jesus received from his mother Mary. The word flesh suggests the living being in its entirety. To eat the flesh of Christ is to eat Christ himself, because the gift of his body involves the gift of his person. Christ’s person becomes food, and this implies on his part the gift of his entire self. The statement, “I am the bread of life” (John 6:35), stresses that Jesus not only gives the bread of eternal life, but that this bread is his very self.

The real presence of the body and blood of Christ in the Eucharist, clearly enunciated in Our Lord’s words, has been received in the tradition of the Church as a truth of faith. It has been repeatedly asserted and commented on by the Fathers. This doctrine developed as a result of certain controversies, with the definitive voice being that of the Council of Trent.

The Council affirmed not only the real presence of Christ’s body and blood, but declared that the entire person of Christ, body, blood, soul, and divinity, is present from the moment of consecration. The eucharistic presence of Christ begins at the moment of the consecration and lasts as long as the eucharistic species subsist. Christ is present whole and entire in each of the species and whole and entire in each of their parts, in such a way that the breaking of the bread does not divide Christ.

Christ is uniquely present in the eucharistic species. The Council of Trent said openly and sincerely, “We profess that within the holy sacrament of the Eucharist, after the consecration of the bread and wine, Our Lord Jesus Christ, true God and true man, is really, truly, and substantially contained under these outward appearances.” He is really present, independent of the faith of the congregation. That is, it is not our faith that makes him present. He is truly present.

Trent used this word against Zwingli, who taught that Christ was only present symbolically. He is substantially present: not merely is the power of Christ present, as Calvin taught, but Christ himself is present, God and man, after the consecration. In this way, the Savior in his humanity is present not only at the right hand of the Father, according to his natural mode of existence, but also in the sacrament of the Eucharist “by a mode of existence which we cannot express in words, but which, with a mind instructed by faith, we can conceive.”

This means that Christ’s presence in the sacrament will always remain a mystery. The fact of the real presence in the Eucharist leads us logically to a consideration of the mystery of transubstantiation through which the real presence is effected. Whenever a priest in the name of Christ pronounces the words of consecration with the intention of doing what the Church does, the bread and wine are changed into the substance of Christ’s body and the substance of Christ’s blood. Christ’s body and blood are produced by an act of divine power through the agency of the priest, as done by Christ himself at the Last Supper.

The decrees of the Council of Trent present transubstantiation and the real presence as logically connected with each other: “But since Christ our Redeemer declared that to be truly his own body which he offered under the form of bread, it has therefore always been a firm belief in the Church of God, and this holy council now declares it anew, that by the consecration of the bread and wine, a change is brought about of the whole substance of bread into the substance of the body of Christ Our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of his blood. This change the holy Catholic Church properly and appropriately calls transubstantiation.”

In other words, it’s only by such a total conversion of the substance of bread and wine into the substance of the Lord’s body and blood that his words, “This is my body… This is my blood,” really mean what they say. “The seeming bread,” said Saint Cyril, “is not bread, though sensible to the taste, but the body of Christ. And the seeming wine is not wine, though the taste will have it so, but the blood of Christ.”

The theory of consubstantiation, that both the bread and Christ’s body are present simultaneously, was rejected by Trent. At the moment of the consecration, the body of Christ is not combined with natural bread, nor is it enclosed in the bread as in a container, but it replaces the substance of the bread while the accidents, color, taste, weight, and so forth, remain in existence and untouched. That the accidents of bread and wine continue to exist even after the substances of bread and wine have been changed is part of the miracle of transubstantiation.

As the body and blood of Christ are one, and are not isolated from one another, so too in the sacrament of the Eucharist, they are found together by concomitance. When the priest says, “This is my body,” Christ’s body is made present, but his blood, soul, and divinity are also present. Similarly, with the consecration of the wine, the blood of Christ is made present, but so also are his body, soul, and divinity.

Through concomitance, then, the whole glorious Christ is in the Eucharist. Referring to this, Trent speaks of “the natural connection through which the parts of the Lord Jesus, who is risen already from the dead, who dies no more, are linked together.” The body is never without the blood, and the blood is never without the body.

Since Christ is present in the sacrament of the Eucharist by transubstantiation, by the change of one substance to another, he is present after the manner of a substance. The Council of Trent says that Christ’s divinity is present after the consecration “on account of its admirable hypostatic union with body and soul.” So, when Christ, having consecrated the wine in the chalice, gave it to his disciples to drink, each of them received the whole Christ, although the quantity of consecrated wine had been divided.

Another consequence of this principle is that the real presence lasts as long as the substance of bread and wine would have remained if transubstantiation had not taken place, that is, as long as the accidents of bread and wine remain. If the appearances of bread and wine cease to be present, then the sacrament no longer exists, nor does the real presence.

Christ is really present in the Eucharist whether or not we believe in him or are open to him. But this offering of himself has to be met by faith if a life-giving encounter is to result. Although we rightly emphasize the conversion of the bread and wine in the Eucharist, it is ultimately the conversion of human hearts that God desires. Thus, in addition to bringing about the transformation of bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ, the Holy Spirit also comes to bring about a transformation of the lives of those who receive the body of Christ. In this way, we become more part of the Church, more united to our community.

When Jesus presented his teaching on the Eucharist at Capernaum, the unbelieving Jews denied his divinity, denied his origin from God the Father, and held him to be an ordinary son of man, the son of Joseph, and so they denied that he was the true bread from heaven. More and more the Savior insisted that he was the true bread, and demanded that they believe it. He showed them that faith was necessary if they wished to be nourished on this life-giving bread. He pointed out that such faith was as much a gift from the Father as is the bread itself, which the Father would give them in his Son.

Undeterred by the Jews’ lack of faith, he went on to set before them the mystery of the bread from heaven. He stated that he intended to give himself as the bread of eternal life, and that he would give us his flesh and blood for our nourishment. Through the medium of his flesh, we were to be united to his person, and through his person, to the Father, so that we might have life from Christ as he has life from the Father. Christ unites himself to us in the Eucharist as the spiritual nourishment of our soul and of our whole being.

The flesh of Christ is to nourish us, not as a mere material flesh with the view of the life of the flesh, but as flesh steeped in the Spirit of God, building us up into a life that is at once divine and spiritual. By partaking of Christ’s flesh, we are illuminated by the light of eternal truth. When we partake of the Eucharist, it nourishes us by conferring upon us the spark of divine life. In the Eucharist, the Son unites himself to us in the most perfect way, and gives us the power to become children of God.

Christ, who gave his body and blood separately to the apostles at the Last Supper, was himself whole and entire at this ritual meal. The Christ whose body and blood is on the altar is whole and entire in heaven. The eucharistic body and blood of the Last Supper were the representation of Christ who would be broken on the cross the following day, not of the Christ there at the head of the table.

Similarly, the eucharistic body and blood on our altars are the representation not of Christ who is in heaven, but of the Christ who was broken on Calvary. The eucharistic sacrifice then is essentially representation. It puts on the altar the Christ of Calvary, the same body that Mary beheld as she gazed on her dead Son hanging on the cross.

In the eucharistic sacrifice, Christ is truly immolated because the immolation of Christ on Calvary is brought home to us in a realistic manner. The Last Supper, which anticipated the death of Jesus, the eucharistic sacrifice, which reenacts it, the biblical narratives which describe it, and even the prophecies and events of the Old Testament which prefigured it, as well as the terrible vision itself on Calvary, are the various disclosures or appearances, the views within which the saving action performed by Christ towards the Father is made manifest and glorified. All these appearances are important, all are essential. It is not for us to argue which of these God might have dispensed with. They are all part of the manifestation of the sacrifice of the cross, and all must be theologically recognized.

By reason of their union with Christ through the Church, the faithful offer the sacrifice with him. They also offer themselves with him. They take part in the Mass, therefore, as those who offer and are offered. On the altar, Jesus Christ presents to God the Father the redeeming meritorious sufferings he underwent on the cross and those of his brothers.

If we live the Mass well, it can transform our lives. “If we have in our souls the same sentiments and intentions as Christ on the cross, we will make our whole life an endless act of atonement, an assiduous petition and a permanent sacrifice for the whole of mankind. God will grant you a supernatural instinct to purify all your actions, raising them to the order of grace and converting them into instruments of apostolate.”

The Lutheran objection to the Catholic doctrine on the eucharistic sacrifice is that the Catholic Church, by teaching the need of a second sacrifice, virtually denies the all-sufficiency of the sacrifice on Calvary. Catholics have always rejected this accusation and affirmed that the sacrifice of the altar and the sacrifice of Calvary are one and the same sacrifice, although they are separated in time. What is made present once again in the Mass is Our Lord’s total, loving submission to his Father’s will.

This internal offering of Christ is identical both in the Mass and on Calvary. It is the same priest, the same victim, the same oblation, and submission to the will of God the Father. The external manifestation of the passion and death of Jesus goes on in the Mass through the sacramental separation in an unbloody manner of the body and blood of Christ. In the Mass, the priest is only the instrument of Christ, the eternal high priest. Christ offers himself in every Mass in the same way as he died on Calvary, although now he does so through the priest, who acts in the person of Christ.

Christ himself in each Mass offers himself up, which is expressed in the separate consecrations of the bread and wine. This is the essence of the holy Mass.

So we can ask Our Lady that we might always be growing in our understanding and love of the holy sacrifice of the altar and approach it with the same fervor and reverence with which she did.

I thank You, my God, for the good resolutions, affections, and inspirations that You have communicated to me during this meditation. I ask Your help to put them into practice. My Immaculate Mother, Saint Joseph, my father and lord, my guardian angel, intercede for me. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

EW

Based on The Most Holy Eucharist, “The Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist” and “The Eucharist as Sacrifice,” by Fr. Thomas J. McGovern (Sophia Institute Press, 2013).