Churches and the Mass

18 min read Eucharist & the Mass

By Fr. Conor Donnelly

(Proofread)

In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

My Lord and my God, I firmly believe that you are here, that you see me, that you hear me. I adore you with profound reverence. I ask your pardon for my sins and grace to make this time of prayer fruitful. My Immaculate Mother, Saint Joseph, my father and lord, my guardian angel, intercede for me.

In churches of East and West, we find the great masterpieces of art—in painting, sculpture, and stained glass—reflecting the eschatological vision of the liturgy.

With the secularization caused by post-Enlightenment thinking, the culture lost its anchorage in the eternal truths and this loss of reference is clearly reflected not only in secular art, but in many of the churches that are built today.

Minimalist spaces, banal exteriors, and disfigured religious art reflect a jarring discontinuity with the accumulated artistic wisdom of the past. Because Christianity is a historical religion, as such it must identify itself with the past to bring Christ into the present. We are told in the Letter to the Hebrews, “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever” (Heb. 13:8).

New and original work should be inspired by this tradition so as to connect artistic and architectural contributions of previous and future generations.

A church should reflect the fact that it provides an environment for the most sacred and sublime action that takes place on this earth. People behave with respect and reverence when they are conscious of being in a sacred place.

In contemporary culture, which has been infected with “the virus of desacralization” (cf. Josef Pieper, In Search of the Sacred), the concept of the sacred is becoming less clear and needs to be affirmed in more specific language.

Hence the requirement at present to emphasize rather than dilute the tradition of Christian art and architecture so that churches immediately communicate a sense of being in a sacred place.

The fact that a church is built to surround an altar on which is reenacted the sacrifice of Calvary is what distinguishes it from every other type of building where people gather. The history of the liturgy shows how the insight and ingenuity of the Christian people down through the centuries has developed many styles of church architecture. From a conviction of faith as to what happens there, certain boundary lines are laid down as regards physical orientation, furniture, and behavior.

While such markers will have a clear significance in relation to the local culture, at the same time, because the celebration of the liturgy has a common universal dimension, it’s not surprising that some elements of church architecture are reflected in every nation.

Nor is it surprising that for a Christian people, who live by faith and see the Mass as the center of existence, the challenge of church architecture would inspire buildings of permanent artistic merit.

The Second Vatican Council has reaffirmed this aspiration when it says, “Holy Mother Church has…always been the patron of the fine arts and has ever sought their noble ministry, to the end especially that all things set apart for use in divine worship should be [truly] worthy, becoming, and beautiful, signs and symbols of things supernatural. …

“Thus, in the course of the centuries, she has brought into existence a treasury of art which must be preserved with every care” (Vatican II, Sacrosantum concilium, Points 122-123, December 4, 1963).

The worship of God unites people and gives their being together its true liturgical meaning. Throughout history this transcendental bonding has taken place in the sacred space set aside for worship, whether in the Temple or the synagogue of the Old Testament, or under the New Covenant, in an oratory, church, or cathedral.

There is a strong parallel between the liturgical arrangements of the sacred places of the two covenants, since, in both, people came together “to hear the word of Scripture and to seal the covenant by means of sacrifice” (cf. Ratzinger, The Spirit of the Liturgy, Part Two, Chapter 2).

Christianity has also learned from the Temple liturgy how to surround the holy place of the sanctuary with “signs of reverence that befit the mysterious presence of God.” When the Jewish synagogue had to be reshaped for Christian worship, we see both “a continuity and a newness in the relationship of the Old Covenant to the New” (cf., ibid., Chapters 2, 3).

One of the challenges of liturgical reform is the recovery of the sense of reverence in churches. Why do many people no longer genuflect when passing in front of the tabernacle? Sometimes we witness chatter before Mass. That can be quite common in some churches. This loss of the sense of the transcendent is due to several factors, not least to a dilution of faith in the Real Presence of Christ in the Blessed Sacrament.

Church design that gives priority to functionalism over beauty does little to encourage people to remain to pray. Certainly, Lumen gentium envisages a higher architectural concept when it uses metaphors such as “the dwelling place of God among men,” “the holy temple,” the image of “the Holy City,” and “the New Jerusalem” to describe a church building (cf. Vatican II, Lumen gentium, Point 6, November 21, 1964).

Sacred architecture should make the world of the spirit perceptible through material construction. Thus St. John Paul II affirms that the church should be “a worthy place for prayer and sacred functions, both for its good order, cleanliness, the neatness with which it is maintained, and for the artistic beauty of its environment, which has a great importance for the way it forms and inspires prayer. For this reason, the Council recommends that the priest properly ‘cultivate liturgical knowledge and art’ (Presbyterorum ordinis, Point 5)” (John Paul II, Address, Point 6, May 12, 1993).

During the autumn of 2009, Pope Benedict XVI devoted some of his Wednesday audiences to address certain considerations of theologians of the Middle Ages. He included a presentation about the art of Gothic cathedrals (Benedict XVI, Address, General Audience, November 18, 2009).

He said that Christian faith, which was “deeply rooted in the men and women of those centuries, not only gave rise to masterpieces of theological literature…” but also “inspired one of the loftiest creations of universal civilization: the cathedrals, true glory of the Middle Ages.

“For almost three centuries, beginning in the eleventh, Europe witnessed an extraordinary artistic and architectural development, especially in relation to its ecclesiastical buildings” (ibid.).

Pope Benedict XVI pointed out a number of factors that contributed to this rebirth. First of all, “historical conditions” were more favorable in that there was greater political security; there was also “a constant increase in population and the development of cities…and wealth.”

Thirdly, stonemason-architects found increasingly elaborate technical solutions to expand the dimensions of buildings, ensuring at the same time their stability and artistic design.

However, Pope Benedict affirmed that it was primarily due to the “spiritual zeal of monasticism, then in full expansion, that abbey churches were erected where the liturgy would be celebrated with dignity and solemnity,” where the faithful could remain to pray, attracted by “the veneration of the relics of the saints,” the object of countless pilgrimages.

In this way Romanesque churches and cathedrals were born, “characterized by their longitudinal development along the naves to house numerous faithful; very solid churches, with thick walls, stone vaults, and simple and essential lines.”

In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, beginning in the north of France, technical advances allowed another type of architecture to develop for the construction of sacred buildings: the Gothic style.

This style had two new characteristics that distinguished it from the Romanesque: a vertical thrust and vibrant luminosity. “Gothic cathedrals,” said Pope Benedict, “were a synthesis of faith and art expressed harmoniously through the universal and fascinating language of beauty, which still today awakens wonder” (ibid.).

With the introduction of ribbed and pointed vaults, supported by robust pillars and buttresses, it was possible to raise notably the height of these churches. The upward thrust of the Gothic was “an invitation to pray;” the architectural lines were an expression in stone of souls longing for God.

“The enclosing walls were punctuated and embellished by large, colorful stained-glass windows, which, scene by scene, provided a catechetical instruction for the people. From these colorful windows, ‘a cascade of light’ was shed on the faithful, narrating the history of salvation and inviting them to be part of that history.

“The people were catechized not only by means of the radiant light from the windows, but also by means of the lavish sculptures in the cathedrals which illustrated the content of the liturgical year.” (ibid.).

The statuary represented episodes from the Gospels, especially the suffering Christ, which was able to inspire piety and repentance of sins. As Pope Benedict pointed out: “With their faces full of beauty, tenderness, intelligence, Gothic sculpture of the thirteenth century reveals a happy and serene piety which is pleased to emanate heartfelt and filial devotion to the Mother of God, seen at times as a young, smiling and maternal woman, and represented primarily as the sovereign of heaven and earth, powerful and merciful” (ibid.).

The faithful who filled the Gothic cathedrals found in them images of the saints who were models of Christian life and intercessors before God. Here, too, they discovered representations of work in the fields, in the sciences, and in the arts, which helped them offer their secular activities in the place where the liturgy was celebrated.

Pope Benedict reminded his audience of two great truths. Firstly, the works of art reflected in the Romanesque and Gothic cathedrals are incomprehensible if one does not take into account the religious soul that inspired them. Secondly, “the forces of the Romanesque style and the splendor of the Gothic cathedrals remind us that the via pulchritudinis, the way of beauty, is a privileged and fascinating way to approach the mystery of God. This beauty is a reflection of the splendor of God, of the Eternal Word made flesh.

“Gradually,” he said, “Gothic architecture replaced the Romanesque, adding height and luminosity to the previous style. The Gothic cathedral translates the aspirations of the soul into architectural lines, and is a synthesis between faith, art, and beauty, which still raises our hearts and minds to God today. When faith encounters art, in particular in the liturgy, a profound synthesis is created, making visible the Invisible” (ibid.).

Liturgy down through the ages has not just been a vehicle for reverence, worship, and prayer; it has also manifested another aspect, that of “abundance and enthusiasm, of generosity, and almost extravagance” (cf. J. Pieper, In Search of the Sacred).

The liturgy has in fact inspired many of the highest expressions of Western culture in architecture, metalwork, painting, stained glass, and sculpture. It was motivated by the conviction that the sacred action of the liturgy transcended all other human activity, and was therefore deserving of the richest expressions of man’s artistic imagination and skill.

Hence we see why Christ would praise the generosity of the woman who used a jar of expensive ointment to prepare his body for burial. He describes what she did as “a beautiful thing” and He promised that her story would be told wherever the Gospel was preached (cf. Mark 14:3-9; Matt. 26:6-13).

What is also striking about the Mosaic liturgy is the largesse and splendor that characterized everything related to the worship of Yahweh. We see this particularly in the instructions Moses received from God for the construction of the Ark and the Tabernacle, which were to be the physical expression of Yahweh’s presence among the Chosen People (cf. Ex. 25-31).

The plates and dishes, flagons and bowls used in the sacrifices were to be of pure gold (cf. Ex. 25:23-30). The seven-branch candlestick was clearly a work of exceptional craftsmanship (cf. Ex. 25:31-40).

Not only were the candle snuffers to be fashioned of gold, but also the very trays on which they rested. The Tabernacle was to be made of silver.

The tabernacle in which the Blessed Sacrament is reserved takes the place previously occupied by the Ark of the Covenant and is the complete fulfillment of what it represented—it is the new Holy of Holies.

The centrality of the Ark to the sanctuary, its beauty of design, and the reverence with which it was held by the Chosen People are all pointers to the very special consideration that should be given to the artistic, architectural, and liturgical presentation of the tabernacle in the churches of the New Covenant.

If the Ark housed merely the symbolic presence of Yahweh, how much more significant is the new Holy of Holies, which contains the real presence of the Incarnate Son of God.

In the revised General Instruction of the Roman Missal, there’s a renewed emphasis on the need for the tabernacle to have a prominent location in churches.

When we come to the question of the priest’s vestments in the Old Testament, we find a description of garments designed for beauty and glory (cf. Ex. 28). They are to be made of the richest material and only by the most accomplished craftsmen. The quality of vestments worn by the Temple priests pointed to the significance of vestments at the celebration of the liturgy of the New Covenant.

The visible appearance of the priest on the altar, the way he is vested, the reverence of his approach to the liturgy—all this can have a profound effect on the people present at Mass. This is because liturgical vestments took their specific form, not because of any practical need stemming from their specific use, but as a consequence of historical association and the cultural environment.

And yet they proclaim loud and clear that for a certain span of time, their wearer is speaking and acting, not as the individual named and described on his driver’s license, but in persona Christi (cf. J. Pieper, In Search of the Sacred).

Vestments are a reminder of that Pauline image of “putting on Christ” (Gal. 3:27). They “are a challenge to the priest to surrender himself to the dynamism of breaking out of the capsule of self, and being fashioned anew by Christ and for Christ.

“They remind those who participate in the Mass of the new way that began with Baptism and continues with the Eucharist, the way that leads to the future world already delineated in our daily lives by the sacraments” (Ratzinger, The Spirit of the Liturgy, Part Four, Chapter 2).

The liturgical vestment has a meaning that goes beyond that of external garments: an anticipation of the new clothing, the risen body of Christ, that new reality which awaits us when the earthly tent is taken down, and which gives us a “place to stay” (cf. John 14:2).

In this context, we can understand more clearly why neglecting to wear appropriate liturgical vestments is one of the abuses reprobated by Church authority.

Participation of the laity in the liturgy is one of the most visible consequences of the liturgical renewal since the Second Vatican Council. Being a priestly people, called to offer spiritual sacrifices, they are empowered to participate actively in the liturgy.

The Mass for them, as for the priest, is the “root and center” (Presbyterorum ordinis, Point 14) of the spiritual life. Thus their very vocation demands a profound participation in the eucharistic sacrifice.

However, a deep understanding of what the Mass is about is the basis for any meaningful involvement in it. But this is not something that can be improvised.

St. John Paul II says, “Conscious participation calls for the entire community to be properly instructed in the mysteries of the liturgy, lest the experience of worship degenerate into a form of ritualism” (John Paul II, Address, Point 3, October 9, 1998).

The Catechism of the Catholic Church provides a wealth of teaching about this central element of the faith, which the priest does well to communicate to his people if they are to appreciate what full and conscious participation in the liturgy means (cf. Catechism, Points 1077-1186, 1322-1405).

Without this knowledge, without this transcendental approach to the liturgy, there is a danger that the Mass will be seen in a reductive manner by the participating congregation, often no more than a way of celebrating its own cultural and religious identity, rather than the objective historical realization of the Redemption accomplished by Christ on the Cross (cf. Aidan Nichols, Looking at the Liturgy).

In this context, St. John Paul II clarified a point that had been a bone of contention: the precise implications of the Council’s call for a “full, conscious, and active participation in the liturgy” (Vatican II, Sacrosanctum concilium, Point 14, December 4, 1963).

Full participation, he says, means that every member of the community has a part to play in the liturgy. Failure to respect the different roles of priest and people could “lead to a clericalizing of the laity and a laicizing of the priesthood” (John Paul II, Address, Point 3, October 9, 1998).

And what does this “active participation” in the liturgy affirmed by the Vatican II mean? Cardinal Ratzinger explains that unfortunately, this participatio actuosa, as it was called, was quickly misunderstood to mean something external, entailing a need for general activity, as if as many people as possible should be visibly engaged in action.

Since “participation” refers to a principal action in which everyone has a part, we must first of all determine what that central action is in which people are supposed to take part.

Basically this is the Eucharistic Prayer, which forms the core of the liturgical celebration. But the Eucharistic Prayer is much more than a speech—it is the actio in the highest sense, the divine action of God.

Because of his ontological bonding with Christ, the being of the priest is mysteriously appropriated by the Word Incarnate and the event of Calvary is re-presented on the altar in an unbloody manner by means of the words, “This is my Body,” “This is my Blood,” spoken through the mouth of the priest. This is the distinctive character of the Christian liturgy by comparison with that of the Old Testament. God Himself acts and does what is essential (cf. J. Ratzinger, The Spirit of the Liturgy, Part Four, Chapter 2).

For the laity, active participation in the liturgy is expressed primarily by uniting with the Sacrifice of the Mass their efforts to sanctify daily work, family life, and social commitments (cf. Vatican II, Lumen gentium, Point 34).

Their participation in the liturgy is more complete when they draw from it the spiritual energy they need to evangelize the culture, bringing Christ and the values of the Gospel into every aspect of human activity (cf. John Paul II, Apostolic Letter, Dies Domini, Point 45, May 31, 1998).

The essential role of the liturgy for the laity is, then, to make them a priestly people in the middle of the world, to activate their capacity to be witnesses to Christ in the home and at work, and, in this way, to sanctify temporal realities.

“The true liturgical action,” said [Cardinal Ratzinger], “is the deed of God, and for that very reason, the liturgy of faith always reaches beyond the cultic act into everyday life, which must itself become ‘liturgical,’ a service for the transformation of the world. Much more is required of the body than carrying objects around and other such activities. A demand is made on the body in all its involvements in the circumstances of everyday life” (J. Ratzinger, ibid.).

John Paul II underscores the relationship between authentic liturgical renewal and effective evangelization. “Insofar as developments in liturgical renewal,” he says, “are superficial or unbalanced, our energies for new evangelization will be compromised; and insofar as our vision falls short of new evangelization, our liturgical renewal will be reduced to external and possibly unsound adaptation. Roman Rite has always been a form of worship that looks to mission.” Even with the Dismissal, the community is sent out “to evangelize the world in obedience to Christ’s command” (John Paul II, Address, Point 4, October 9, 1998).

So we could ask Our Lady that we might also take note of the great historical, liturgical, artistic legacy that we have in our churches, in our art, in our altars, in our stained-glass windows, and so many other aspects—all those material things that speak to us.

We are reminded of the words of John Paul II, that we “go to the great spiritual mysteries through those physical signs and symbols” (John Paul II, Theology of the Body: Human Love in the Divine Plan; cf. Catechism of the Catholic Church, Point 1146).

Mary, may you help us to grow and appreciate all these wonderful things.

I thank you, my God, for the good resolutions, affections, and inspirations that you have communicated to me during this meditation. I ask your help to put them into practice. My Immaculate Mother, Saint Joseph, my father and lord, my guardian angel, intercede for me.

In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

EW

Based on The Most Holy Eucharist, “The Eucharistic Liturgy,” by Fr. Thomas J. McGovern (Sophia Institute Press, 2013).